With the release of DaVinci Resolve 11, Blackmagic Design has firmly moved into the ranks of nonlinear editing. In addition to a redesigned logo and splash screen, Resolve 11 sports more editorial tools than ever before. Now for the first time it is worthy for consideration as your NLE of choice. I have covered previous releases of Resolve, so I’ll only briefly touch on color correction in this article.
As before, DaVinci Resolve 11 comes in four versions: Resolve Lite (free), Resolve Software ($995), Resolve (with the control surface for $29,995) and the Linux configuration. Both free and paid versions support a variety of third-party control surfaces, with the most popular being the Avid Artist Color and the Tangent Devices Element panels. Resolve Lite supports output up to UltraHD (3840 x 2160). It includes most of the features of the paid software, except collaboration, stereo 3D and noise reduction. Although you can operate Resolve without any third-party i/o hardware, if you want external monitoring or output to tape, you’ll need to purchase one of Blackmagic Design’s PCIe capture cards or Thunderbolt i/o devices.
The interface is divided into four modules: media, edit, color and deliver. All color correction occurs in the color module. Here you’ll find a wealth of grading tools, including camera raw settings, color wheels, primary sliders and more. Color Match is a new correction tool. If you included a color chart when you shot your footage, Resolve can use the image of that chart to set an automatic correction for the color balance of the scene.
Color Match features three template settings for charts, including X-Rite ColorChecker, Datacolor SpyderCheckr and DSC Labs OneShot. If you used one of these charts and it’s in your footage, then select the appropriate set of color swatches in the Color Match menu. Next, select the Color Chart grid from the viewer tools, which opens an overlay for that chart. Corner-pin the overlay so that the grid lines up over the color swatches in the image and hit the Match button. Resolve will instantly adjust its curves to correct the color balance of the shot, so that the chart in the image matches the template for that chart in Resolve. Now you can copy this grade and apply it to the rest of the shots within that same set-up.
Although this isn’t a one-shot fix, it’s intended to give you a good starting point for your grade. While this feature demos really well and is certainly a whizz-bang attention-getter, it has the most value for novice users or for DITs who need to get a quick grade for dailies while on location.
The biggest spark of interest I’ve seen for Resolve 11 is due to the editing tools. As an NLE, it’s somewhat of a mash-up between Final Cut Pro 7 and Final Cut Pro X. It copies a lot of X’s design aesthetic and even some features, like clip skimming in the media bins; yet, it is clearly track-based. For editors who like a lot of FCP X, but are put off by Apple’s trackless, magnetic timeline, Resolve 11 becomes a very tantalizing, cross-platform alternative.
Resolve 11’s edit module most closely aligns with Final Cut Pro 7, although there is no multi-cam feature, yet. The keyboard commands mirror the FCP 7 set, as do menu options and much of the working style. One big improvement is a very advanced trim mode, which offers good asymmetrical trimming. If you start a project from the beginning in Resolve 11, you can easily import media, organize clips into bins/folders, add logging information and, in general, do all of the nuts-and-bolts things you do in every editing application.
The interface uses a modal design and supports dual and single monitor configurations. Although there are numerous panels and windows that can be opened as needed, the general layout is fixed. Certain functions are restricted to the edit module and others to the color module. For example, transition effects, titles and generators would be added and adjusted in the edit module, while working with a standard timeline. Color correction and other image effects are reserved for the color module, which uses a node-based hierarchy. Resizing and repositioning can be done in either.
Resolve includes an inspector pane on the right side of the timeline viewer that is much like that of FCP X. Here you’ll find composite, transform, cropping, retiming and scaling controls. If you select a transition, then its adjustment controls appear in the inspector panel. Resolve supports the OpenFX video plug-in architecture. Third-party transitions will show up in the edit mode’s OpenFX library, while the filters only show up when you are in the color mode. Like FCP X, inspector controls are limited to sliders, color pickers and numerical entry, with no allowance for custom third-party plug-in interfaces.
My biggest beef is performance. Resolve 11 is optimized to pass the highest quality images through its pipeline, which seems to impede real-time playback, even with ungraded footage. In other NLEs, hitting play or the space bar brings you to full-speed, real-time playback in a fraction of a second. In Resolve it takes a few seconds, which is clearly evident in its dropped-frame indicator. Even with proper real-time playback, video motion does not look as smooth and fluid in the viewer as I would expect. There are a number of factors that affect this, including drive performance (high-performance storage is good), GPU performance (one or more high-end cards are desirable) and age of the machine (a new top-of-the-line system is ideal). Resolve is also not as gracious with a wide range of native media types as some of the other NLEs.
Color grades will affect performance. What if you start grading in the color mode and bounce back into the edit mode? This has the same impact on the computer as applying several filters in a traditional NLE. Add a stack of effects on most NLEs and playback performance through those clips is often terrible until you render. To mitigate this issue, Resolve includes smart caching, which is a similar sort of background render as that of FCP X. The software renders clips with a grade or an effect applied anytime the machine is idle.
Audio in Resolve 11 is still in the very early stages. There is no audio plug-in architecture. Hopefully Blackmagic will add AU and/or VST support down the road. Having multiple audio tracks also hurts system performance. Complex audio in the timeline quickly choked my system. Having even a few tracks caused the audio to drop out during playback. Resolve employs a similar track design to Adobe Premiere Pro. This means adaptive tracks, where a single timeline track can contain one mono channel, two stereo channels or multiple surround channels. This is an interesting design, but it seems to impact round-tripping between other applications. For example, I’ve exported multi-channel timelines via XML. In this process, when I brought that timeline into FCP 7 or Premiere Pro, these tracks only showed up as mono tracks with one channel of audio.
Where Resolve 11 really shines is in its roundtrip capabilities. It can take media and edit list formats from a range of systems, then let you process the media and finally output a new set of media files and corresponding lists. EDL, AAF, XML and FCPXML formats are supported, making Resolve 11 one of the better cross-application conversion tools. For instance, you can edit in FCP X, conform and grade in Resolve 11 and then output that in a compatible format to finish in the same or different NLE, such as Media Composer, Smoke, Premiere Pro, etc. Of course, with Resolve 11, you could simply finish in Resolve and output final deliverables from right within the application. That’s clearly the design goal Blackmagic had in mind.
Personally, I still prefer to use the roundtrip method, but there are a few wrinkles in this process. I have already mentioned audio issues. Another is resizing, such as FCP X’s “spatial conform” and Premiere Pro’s “scale to frame size”. These are automatic timeline functions to fit oversized images into smaller timeline frames, such as putting 4K media into a 1080 timeline. This feature automatically down-scales the source image so that either horizontal or vertical dimensions match. Unfortunately some of this information gets lost in the translation between applications.
I recently ran into this on two jobs with 4K RED media and Resolve 11. The first was a project cut in FCP X. The roundtrip went fine, but when the newly rendered 1080 media was back in FCP X, the application still thought it needed to enable spatial conform, which had been used in the offline edit. Disabling spatial conform caused FCP X to blow up the 1080 media 200%. The simple fix was just to leave spatial conform on and let FCP X render this media on export. There were no visible issues that I could detect.
The second was a music video project that the director had cut on Premiere Pro CC2014. There was extensive reframing and repositioning throughout. Importing this timeline into Resolve 11 was a complete disaster and would have meant rebuilding all of this work to reframe images. Ultimately I opted to use SpeedGrade CC2014 on this particular job, since it correctly translated the Premiere Pro timeline via Adobe’s Direct Link feature.
As a general rule, I would recommend that if you know you are going outside of the application, do not use any of these automatic resizing tools in the offline NLE. Instead, manually set the scale and position values, because Resolve does an excellent job of interpreting these parameters when set during the offline edit.
Blackmagic added the OpenFX architecture with Resolve 10, but now that Resolve 11 is out, new developers are joining the party. On my test system I installed both the FilmConvert 2.0 plug-in and the Boris Continuum Complete 9 package. The filters are accessed in the color modules and are applied to nodes, just like other grading functions. Although other host versions of the FilmConvert filter include color wheels within the filter’s control panel, they are excluded in the OpenFX version. You do get the camera and film emulsion presets. This is my favorite film emulation and grain plug-in and it makes a suitable complement to Resolve.
Boris FX’s BCC 9 for Resolve includes most of the same filters as for other hosts, including the new FX Browser. You can launch it from inside the Resolve interface, but when I tried to use it, the browser crashed the application. I’m running the public beta of 11.1, so that could be part of it. Otherwise, the filters themselves worked fine. So, if you need to add a glow, cartoon effect or spray paint noise to a shot, you can do so from inside Resolve with BCC 9.
OpenFX filters installed for other applications also show up in Resolve. I discovered this during my review of the HP Z1G2 workstation. Sony Vegas Pro 13 was installed, which also uses OpenFX. The NewBlueFX filters that were installed for Vegas also showed up in Resolve 11 on that machine.
A key point to remember it to apply OpenFX filters in a separate node. If you need to change the filter, simply delete the node and create a new one for a different filter. That way you won’t lose any of the correction applied to the clip.
Resolve 11 enables collaboration among multiple users on the same project. This requires a paid version of Resolve 11 for each collaborator, a network and a shared DaVinci Resolve database. To test this feature, I enlisted the help of colorist and trainer Patrick Inhofer (Tao of Color, Mixing Light). Patrick set up a simple ethernet network between a Mac Pro and a MacBook Pro, each running a paid version of Resolve 11. You have to set up a shared project and open both Resolve seats in the collaboration mode. Once both systems are open with the same project, then it is possible to work interactively.
This is not like two or more Avid Media Composers running in a Unity-style sharing configuration. Rather, this approach is intended for an editor and a colorist to be able to simultaneously work on one timeline at the same time. One person is the “owner” of the project, while anyone else is a “collaborator”. In this model, the “owner” has control of the editing timeline and the “collaborator” is the colorist working in the color module. You could also have a third collaborator logging metadata for clips.
In the collaboration mode, a bell-shaped alert icon is added to the lower left corner of the interface. Whenever the colorist adds or changes a correction on one or more clips and publishes his changes, the editor receives an alert to update the clips. When the update is made, the colorist’s changes become visible on the clips in the editor’s timeline. If the editor makes editorial changes to the timeline, such as trimming, adding or deleting clips, then he or she must save the project. Once saved, the colorist can reload the project to see these updates.
As long as you follow these procedures, things work well; however, in our tests, when we went the other direction, updates didn’t happen correctly. For example, color changes made by the editor or timeline edits made by the colorist, did not show up as expected on the other person’s system. Collaboration worked well, once we both got the hang of it, but the feature does feel like a 1.0 version. Updating changes worked, but you can also reject a change by choosing “revert”. This is supposed to take the clip back to the previous grade. Instead, it dropped the grade entirely and went back to an un-corrected version of the clip with all nodes removed.
DaVinci Resolve 11 is a powerful new version of this best-in-class color grading application. Although you might not edit a project from start-to-finish in Resolve, you certainly could. For now, Blackmagic Design is positioning Resolve as an NLE designed for finishing. Edit your creative cut in Media Composer, Final Cut Pro or Premiere Pro – mix in Logic Pro X, Pro Tools or Audition – and then bring them all together in Resolve 11. As we all know, clients like to tweak the cut until the very end. Now the grading environment can enjoy more interactivity than ever before.
©2014 Oliver Peters